Skip to content

DeerfieldPrep by EduAvenues is an independent service, not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Deerfield Academy.

All guides

Deerfield Essays: Short Answer, Personal and Graded Essay

Deerfield asks for three essays: a short answer, a personal essay and a graded essay with teacher comments. Here is what the school says and what it leaves out.

Deerfield's application has three pieces of writing in Part II: a Short Answer, a Personal Essay and a Graded Essay. The graded essay is the unusual one, because it's a paper your child already wrote for a class, with the teacher's comments still on it.

The school's own guidance on that paper is the most useful line on the page: "A paper that shows thoughtful teacher commentary and your effort to improve is more valuable to us than one that simply received a high grade."

The three parts of Part II

Per Deerfield's start-your-application page, Part II of the Gateway application has these three:

  • Short Answer.
  • Personal Essay.
  • Graded Essay.

The page names them, but the pages we reviewed don't list the prompts or word limits. We aren't going to guess them. Prompts for the Gateway application can change by year, so read them inside your child's own application.

The graded essay, explained

The graded essay needs teacher comments from a current course. So the paper has to come from this year's class work, not from an older class.

Here's what the school's line tells you.

  • A high grade by itself isn't the point. A strong paper with no comments gives the reader nothing to learn from.
  • Thoughtful teacher commentary is the point. The reader wants to see what the teacher noticed.
  • Visible effort to improve counts. A paper where the student clearly took feedback and moved forward is the kind the school describes.

Deerfield doesn't say how long the paper should be or which subject it must be from. It says the paper needs teacher comments and comes from a current course. If the pages we reviewed are all you have, those are the only rules you can rely on.

How to choose a paper

You can't choose well after the fact, so start early in the fall. Here are some practical questions to ask.

  • Does the paper have real comments, not just a number or a check mark?
  • Did your child revise it, or can they explain what they would change?
  • Can your child talk about it in the interview? Deerfield's interview is one-on-one, and a paper they understand well is easy to discuss.

If a class paper has light comments, ask the teacher whether they can add a few. That's a reasonable request early in the term and a harder one in January.

Writing the personal essay

Deerfield doesn't publish a prompt on the pages we read, so we can't say what the personal essay asks. What you can do is keep the process sound. Let your child write it. A parent's job is to read it, ask questions, and notice where it doesn't sound like them. Editing for grammar is fine. Rewriting isn't, and admissions readers can tell.

Other writing in the application

Part III holds the recommendations from three academic teachers and a principal or counselor. An additional letter from a past or present teacher is optional. Deerfield says most applicants don't need to submit supplemental materials, so don't treat extra writing as a way to stand out.

Timing

The priority deadline is January 15, and decisions come March 10. Because the graded essay depends on a current course, plan the paper in fall, not winter. The school also says that if you finish after the deadline it can't guarantee a March 10 decision.

What Deerfield doesn't say

The pages we reviewed don't give essay length limits, scoring rules, or how much weight any one essay carries. They also don't say whether a parent statement is part of the application, so check the checklist in your child's Admission Portal.

Frequently asked questions

Does the graded essay have to come from a current class?

Yes. The school says the graded essay needs teacher comments from a current course.

Should we pick the paper with the highest grade?

Not necessarily. Deerfield says a paper with thoughtful teacher commentary and visible effort to improve is more valuable than one that simply earned a high grade.

Are the essay prompts published?

Not on the pages we reviewed. Read the prompts inside the Gateway application before your child starts writing.

Sources

For the full checklist logic, read the admissions overview. For help planning the year, see the preparation page.

DeerfieldPrep by EduAvenues is an independent service, not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Deerfield Academy.